Skip to main content

Debate on Salman Sheedi's Point of View


Salman Sheedi posted his point of view on Iqbal. It is very interesting indeed. Iqbal by Niaz would like to have an informed and reasoned debate on it. Here is Salman Sheedi's text:


Subhanallah and Mashallah does not work. It is an opium which only hurts nations and Pakistan is a good example where over the board religion has created numerous crisis in the country. Iqbal was a depressed totally broke failed person who used religion to get some recognition, but his ideals were tribal and arrogant. There is no truth in what he says....

Idolising Iqbal is very dangerous for Pakistan particularly youths. We need to idolize progressive, secular, law abiding citizens and free thinkers,so the nation can create better educated citizens. Iqbal Philosophy of life is based on immature religious thinking which is making the Pakistani nation Arab slaves for free. And Arab don't even appreciate it and treat them like dirt. Iqbal is one confused average poet who is liked by Mullahs, Communists and Capitalists alike. He talks of democracy and then supports Sharia Law which is totally dictatorial Mullah monopoly law. Sharia System of Laws is about giving power to an individual with all administrative, legislative and judicial powers. The ruler can not be removed even if he is in comma. (You have just watched it in Saudi Arabia where the King was in bed for ten years, but can not be displaced. King Adbullah had to wait 10 years until he breathed his last. See in Iran where Khomeini was replaced only he stopped breathing.. Although he was almost 90 years old. Both have Sharia System as their law where women have half rights than man. What do you want? Give Sharia law power to Zardari and Nawaz untill they breath last?  Anyone who say he can change the law by consensus or what they call Ijtehad is living in fool's paradise. The Mullah will never allow that because changing sharia will open the flood gate of changes (because Sharia is so primitive and tribal based) which will endanger their power. So forget about changing sharia to comply modern living standards. Why to even go there. Keep religion personal (which Quaid-e-Azam wanted and visioned) because we are multi-sect country and each sect has different sharia and Fiqha. Why empower Mullah who were not even in favor of Pakistan's creation. Why deny the rights of 95% of peaceful secular Pakistanis who want to help their country and make it a developed and progressive country where everyone including women have equal rights. Sharia has no rights for women. It is only for man. Sharia and Democracy which is based on respect of life, human rights can't co-exists. Pakistanis already have a great leader as their idol who single handed created the largest Muslim country of his time through hard work dedication, faith and discipline. And by the way Iqbal was against the creation of Pakistan. Please read his letters to his own teacher Professor Arnold where he clearly said he is against the creation of Pakistan. In his 1930 Allah bad address he asked of many Muslim majority countries under Indian constitution as a confederation under British or Indian Central Govt. That is in no way a demand for Pakistan. All this hoopla that Jinnah somehow was working under the influence of Iqbal is totally unfounded and is not supported by his historians... Iqbal was a political failure during his time as president of Punjab Muslim League and only has two seats in Punjab Assembly. Folks read the history, follow the true leader not copycat Philosopher (who took German Poetry and translated it in Persian and Urdu.. Laugh out loud, who wasted all his life in extra marital affairs looking for beautiful wife.

The best example we have is Quaid-e-Azam who rose from a poor family, became the most successful lawyer of his time, was appreciated by every political force when in politics for 50 years, made millions, lived as he wanted to live and was a leader of principle, faith and discipline. He donated millions to schools and colleges of Pakistan to help create great leaders of future. Iqbal although equally qualified and Bar-at-Law was a failed person who was looking for stipends in his later life to survive. Who do you want as your mentor a successful person or failed person who could only create Arab slaves on fake stories or law breakers.. We inform, you decide...

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

6321 kanals of land transferred to CUs for creation of infrastructure: Malik

GNS JAMMU MAR,01 :Minister for Higher Education, Mr. Abdul Gani Malik today informed the Legislative Assembly that about 4641 kanals and 4325 kanals of land has been indentified for the establishment of the Central Universities at Jammu and Kashmir respectively, out of which 3000 kanals and 3321 kanals stands transferred to these Universities. He said the process of transferring the remaining land is in progress. The Minister was replying to question of Mr. Yashpal Kundal in the House. The Minister said that the job of land survey and contour mapping has been assigned to Educational Consultants India Limited (EDCIL) after which master plans will be formulated and the construction work taken up. He said at present both the Central Universities are functional in the rental accommodation. He said MA English and comparative Literature, PG in Applied Mathematics, PG in Economics and M Phil in English courses have been introduced in Jammu University whereas 6 more courses are likely being...
Post a Comment
Read more

Ravinder Sharma MLC 2 Days Tour Of Sunderbani n Nowshehra Conclude

GNS Sunderbani,September 01 : Member Legislative Council Mr. Ravinder Sharma-General Secretary & Spokesperson JKPCC conducted two days tour of Nowshera-Sunderbani areas of Rajouri district & addressed series of public meetings and took stock of problems of people. Addressing the meetings at Nonial, Chowki, Bhawani, Sunderbani, Soit, Chhatta and Mudwal, Mr. Sharma said that Congress party alone can guarantee for the unity and integrity of the state and take the nation to the path of peace and prosperity. Mr. Sharma lashed out     at the policies of communal and divisive forces to exploit the situation for vested political interests. He cautioned the people against the designs of such political parties and advised them to follow the path of secularism and work to strengthen the unity and integrity of the state and the nation. Number of prominent persons joined Congress party. They appreciated the policies and programmes of Congress party and the workings of...
Post a Comment
Read more

Simultaneous alliance with Congress and BJP exhibits NC’s brazen political opportunism: PDP “Offering ‘ministerial berth’ bait manifests Omar’s insecurity”

GNS Srinagar, Nov 30: Terming Chief Minister Omar Abdullah’s latest move of courting BJP as his new allies a brazen show of opportunism, opposition Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) today said the National Conference has taken the political immorality to a new low by simultaneously entering into coalition of expedience with Congress and BJP. “As NC has always survived on trickery, its latest move to woo back its old allies (BJP) is in tune with the party’s philosophy of political opportunism and deceit,” PDP chief spokesman Naeem Akhtar said in a statement issued here today. He said, curiously, developing NC-BJP bonhomie coincides with the recent visit of senior BJP leader and Rajya Sabha member Arun Jaitley in Jammu. Terming Omar Abdullah’s ‘ministerial berth’ bait a desperate attempt to keep the dissipating NC flock together and fully exploit disgruntled party legislators for upcoming Legislative Council polls,  Akhtar said Abdullahs have a history of adopting ‘use-a...
Post a Comment
Read more